Causation problems and considerations in the criminal law. Causation in criminal law is concerned with whether the defendants conduct contributed sufficiently to the prohibited consequence to justify the criminal liability, which would be assessed from two aspects, namely factual and legal causation. Causation in law is an example of the actus reus which is the active element in a crime. Secondly, even if the criteria suggested for selecting caudation conditions as causes are in place in explanatory inquiries they are not. Introduction the long awaited high court decision of chappel v. This new edition of the seminal 1959 work retains the original analysis of commonsense causal concepts, and includes hundreds of new decisions and a substantial preface in which criticisms are met and a rationale propounded for commonsense causal notions as an element in legal responsibility. How might moral responsibility and legal responsibility come apart, even in a just legal. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months. Humphhies mount allisonuniversity general causation in the law. Causation in the law jn spite of all the work that has been done on the subject of causation 1 there are questions about the concept of cause that have been little discussed. Discussions of causation are much less prominent in books about contract than in books about tort. A member of the ness set is a causally relevant condition. An individual user may print out a pdf of a single chapter of a monograph in oso for personal use. An updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its wellknown predecessor which claimed that courts employ commonsense notions of causation in determining legal responsibility.
Causation in insurance contract law also comes with a foreword written by professor robert merkin. Hart1, hailed as the most important decision in the realm of medical negligence since rogers v. In the first place, the harm for which compensation is to be paid in the law of contract is usually economic rather than physical, and establishing causal connection between a breach of contract and economic loss. Read the fulltext online edition of causation in the law 1959. Hart and honore are unable to provide a sound philosophical basis for the criminal law of causation in their causation in the law, and that another, more critical, analysis is required to explain, if not to rationalise, the vagaries of the law in this area. Recently in england, however, an attempt was made to reduce causation to a problem of responsibility. As we proceed to describe what the laws concept of causation is, we should be eclectic on what these values are. An updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its wellknown predecessor which claimed that courts employ commonsense notions of causatio. Hart honore causation in the law pdf pdf encyclopedia. One can see their concept most easily in three steps.
Including the but for test of factual causation and legal causation. Tony honore oxford university press it is a civil wrong to cause injury to another by negligence in driving a vehicle, but the claim is barred or reduced if the negligent conduct of the person injured is also a cause of the injury. In most conventional criminal law cases, causation is a straightforward matter. Causation and responsibility excerpt from causation in the law, hart and. In causation in the law 1959, hebert hart and tony honore attempted to set forth a set of allegedly causal principles, supposedly deeply embedded in ordinary thought, for identifying causes and attributing legal responsibility. How do questions of causal responsibility bear on questions of legal responsibility. Session 1 hart and honore, selections from causation in.
For them, there are degrees of causal contribution. Sthe concept of causation asit is foundin legaldiscourse. In moral case, we make judgments of responsibility to assign praise and blame, to. Session 12 hart and honore, selections from causation in the law.
Causation and opportunity in tort oxford journal of legal. This text is an updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its. The aim of this paper is to present a framework which provides an acceptable explanation of, and justification for, the pattern of the cases and the statutory provisions. Hart, was a british legal philosopher, and a major figure in political and legal philosophy. An updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its wellknown predecessor which claimed that courts employ commonsense notions of. Hart honore causation in the law pdf chris may field.
The third of these alternatives, which has roots in hart and honores 1985 treatment of causation in the law, treats causation as relative to default states, which encode the states that are considered normal and natural, as opposed to the deviant states. Causation plays a central role in the law, from assessing criminal responsibility for outcomes to apportioning damages to victims. Causation is widely regarded as presenting very difficult issues for criminal law. Herbert lionel adolphus, 1907publication date 1962 topics proximate cause law publisher oxford. Causation in criminal law abstract despite difficulties associated with the law of causation, it could be much clearer than it is. Hart and honore, in their famous work causation in the law, also tackle the problem of too many causes.
Causation in the law and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. All readings will be on sakai, but it is recommended that you purchase hart and honores. Whereas the former component concerns the minimum requirements an. Jun 30, 2019 hart honore causation in the law pdf causation in the law. This volume offers, for the first time, a detailed exchange between legal and philosophical scholars over moores most recent work.
Novus actus interveniens in medical cases and the egg shell skull rule are considered with case summaries. Causation and causality have been debated for centuries in philosophy, and there are thousands of books and articles on the topic, including some very recent. Causation in the law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. This chapter maintains that there is no satisfactory analysis of causation in non causal terms in the huge philosophical literature on the topic. Hart and tony honore argue that causation in the law is based on causation outside the law, that the causal principles the courts rely on to determine legal responsibility are based on distinctions exercised in ordinary causal judgments. Jn spite of all the work that has been done on the subject of causation. Hart honore causation in the law pdf causation in the law. Philosophers have argued ad nausea about the law of universal causation. I believe that it was generated by harts attempt, in both causation in the law and his writings on legal positivism, to defend law and legal reasoning against the. Causation and opportunity in tort oxford journal of. Obviously, a great many cases at law involve such transactions between plaintiff and defendant, but i cannot take the space here to discuss harts and honores. This new edition of the seminal 1959 work retains the original analysis of commonsense causal concepts.
Professors hart and honore responded with a warning against a general elimina. Closely reasoned, with full reference to the literature and a considerable treatment of continental theories, it represents a serious attempt to restate the law in tort, contract and crime in an intelligible way. Introduction the legal maxim take your victim as you find him 228 is wellknown in both english criminal and tort law, as well as in many other legal systems. As we proceed to describe what the laws concept of causation is. University of missouri school of law scholarship repository faculty publications fall 1992 causation in fact in omission cases. Causality and causation in law scandinavian studies in law.
Pdf causation in the law download full pdf book download. In addition, the author expertly applies causation questions in concrete scenarios, and ultimately, this book provides a single volume solution to a very complex but essential question of insurance law and tort law. The starting point of the first edition of this work published in 1959 was the claim that courts in determining legal responsibility employ commonsense notions of causation. Aug 14, 2019 hart honore causation in the law pdf causation in the law. However, causation problems can occur whenever criminal liability requires a specific outcome. Hart and tony honore abstract this text is an updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its wellknown predecessor which claimed that courts employ commonsense notions of causation in determining legal responsibility. Oct 24, 2017 for similar reasons, although i will be drawing on harts insights about the justificatory significance of a persons having the opportunity to choose what will happen in a situation, i have no stakes in defending harts quite different account of causation in tort law, as laid out in his seminal work with tony honore.
Beginning with a series of articles in the 1950s and culminating in their massive book of 1959, causation in the law, second edition 1985, herbert hart and tony honore sought to describe the idea of intervening causation that they saw the law adopting from everyday causal idioms. Influenced by such usage, hart and honore asserted that both the question of historical contribution and the question of truncation of responsibility were causal questions. Use the link below to share a fulltext version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Session 1 hart and honore, selections from causation in the law. It may, of course, well be that when we thoroughly understand the commonsense notions of causation we should no longer wish our thought on any matters, let alone legal judgments of responsibility, to be dominated by them. This is elevated into a cause where it is a deliberate human intervention, or. This text is an updated and extended second edition supporting the findings of its wellknown.
Hart honore causation in the law pdf causation in the. What the law of causation needs to be if it is to serve the values constituting the function of the rules in which causation appears, thus makes a considerable difference to what the law of causation is. It will be of interestto historians becauseof the many illuminatingparallelsit drawsbetween the linguistic conventions of historyandthe law. Due to its scope and depth, moores causation and responsibility is probably the most important publication in the philosophy of law since the publication of harts and honores causation in the law in 1959. The metaphysics of causation stanford encyclopedia of. Hart and tony honore causation comprises two components. The early chapters deal philosophically with the concept of cause and are clearly the work of hart, while later chapters deal with individual cases in. An overview of the law relating to causation in criminal liability. Causation in the law herbert lionel adolphus hart, tony. Someone commits a criminal action, which is the cause of a crime.
191 1522 307 589 87 1513 928 818 1415 846 1243 367 1329 691 631 621 245 1151 655 1139 696 1569 525 1456 1462 1613 1614 1235 423 463 276 1425 1313 35